Robert Feinberg spoke with Brad Beard, owner of Mercury Wine.
Transcript
Robert Feinberg: Welcome. As many of you know, the First Press Wine Festival is approaching in February of this upcoming new year. And we’re super excited to have here today with us Brad Beard, who is the owner of Mercury Wine in Sonoma County. Brad, welcome.
Brad Beard: Thank you. Thank you very much for having me. I’m excited to get out there to Phoenix.
Robert Feinberg: Yeah, Brad. I’m Robert Feinberg and it’s a pleasure to meet you here today.
Brad Beard: Likewise.
Robert Feinberg: So tell us a little bit about your wine journey. How did you get started in wine?
Brad Beard: Um, I like to say it was one bad decision after another. But, I was born and raised actually in Phoenix to parents who didn’t drink wine. And so, I really wasn’t exposed to wine growing up. Exposed more to some fine beers and some beautiful tequila, some nice margaritas, but wasn’t really born and raised into a wine-consuming family.
But then we fast forward a little bit, and I ended up working at a Michelin-rated restaurant. And if you worked there, you had to learn about wine. The master sommelier and the catering director discovered that I had a sensitive palate and I really enjoyed the wines. So from there, I realized, “Wow, you could be a sommelier and fly around the world and learn all these great things about wines.” And so I started going down that track.
I ended up as a regional wine buyer for a while, and then as an importer and distributor. As an importer and distributor, that’s how I learned how to make wine from my good winemaking friends—not just here in California, but from France, Italy, and Spain. And one of my best friends, Rob Gibson from Gibson Family Wines or Loose Ends out in Australia.
Then I started making wine, and then I decided this was really what I wanted to do. We started making wine in 2005 and we opened up our tasting room in downtown Geyserville in 2008. So, it’s been a really interesting journey for me, and I still learn something new about wine every single day. That’s why I truly love it.
Robert Feinberg: Excellent. Now, Geyserville is in Sonoma County, right?
Brad Beard: Yes, it is. Just a little bit west of our Napa friends.
Robert Feinberg: Sure. And that’s great wine country all the way around, so you just can’t go wrong there.
Brad Beard: Yes, it really is. And I chose Geyserville specifically since I wasn’t born and raised out here. If you look at the three valleys right here, you have Alexander Valley—world-class Cabernet, Chardonnay. You’ve got Dry Creek right out behind me, which truly saved Zinfandel, but of course grows the Cab and the Chard and many Rhône varietals. And then Russian River, just 5 miles to the south of me.
So to me, it’s like the mecca of wine. As a winemaker, not necessarily a grower, it gives me access to world-class grapes. There’s nowhere else in the world that you can grow world-class Pinot Noir and world-class Cabernet within 15 miles of each other. So for me, this is just where I needed to be. I just love everything about this location.
Robert Feinberg: Absolutely, and I couldn’t agree more. You mentioned the distinction between a maker and a grower. Tell us what you mean by that.
Brad Beard: Well, okay. I’ve got many, many friends who started out as grape growers and then moved into winemaking. Then there’s a lot of folks out there like me that enjoy making wine, but do not grow all of our own grapes.
It’s a great question because we both want the same thing, but have two different ways to get there. All great growers—you could talk about all the great houses usually sell some of their grapes to somebody, so let’s pretend I was getting grapes from a fancy winery, well named and such. Grape growers are trying to grow the highest quality grape, but get it off the vine as soon as possible. That’s their thing. As a grape grower, you might want to grow as much as you can to make as much money as you can.
But for me as a wine producer—I’ve only been making wine for 20 years, so I need to have the highest quality grape possible to make the finest wine. I’m not clever enough to take an average grape that was grown and turn it into something spectacular. So I have to have the absolute highest quality grapes, which means that we need to have, for the vineyard site and location, the right amount of tonnage that’s going to be coming per acre.
Large mass-production wineries will have 10 tons, 12 tons, 15 tons per acre. I don’t think any of my vineyards produce more than five; some of them produce one and two tons per acre. So I’m out there trying to get the absolute highest quality. Sometimes other farmers, but not the ones I’m working with, are just trying to grow as much as they can to make as much as they can. So we always have these little battles on how we’re going to farm and finish the wine. I always want to drop more fruit; they want to keep fruit on. Canopy and all of those things going into having the highest quality wine is my number one concern.
Robert Feinberg: Understood. I realize that you’re going to be at the First Press Wine Festival on February 20th. Tell us, have you done it before?
Brad Beard: No, this is my first time. I have wanted to do it for the last three or four years, but we had scheduling conflicts with my schedule and stuff like that. This year it worked out perfectly, so I’m super excited to be there.
Robert Feinberg: That’s great. Let me just say, I was there last year and it was absolutely, positively spectacular. A lot of good growers and makers were there, to use your distinction, and there was also some really fabulous food and a really collegial, fun crowd. So I’m confident you’re going to just have a lovely time and enjoy it very much while you’re there.
What sorts of knowledge do you plan on imparting to the guests who might be roaming around looking to meet you, particularly after seeing you on this video? You’re obviously a made man when it comes to wine; you worked yourself through the ranks, and now it sounds like you’re blending some really great juice. So tell us, what kind of knowledge do you plan to impart and share?
Brad Beard: Well, that’s just a fantastic question. When I was growing up in the wine business, you had the sommeliers and you had the people who were wealthy enough to travel to Europe and learn about wine. That knowledge was sort of kept to themselves. I love giving out my knowledge and telling people what I think about growing, grape production, and blending.
20 years ago, I’m a firm believer in blending wine. America can produce great 100%, but my philosophy is: if we’ve got the best Cab, the best Merlot, and the best Cabernet Franc, why wouldn’t we want to put those three things together and create something even better than the wine?
So, I love busting myths about wine. Wine—my goodness, yes, fancy people have consumed it. One of my favorite regions is Châteauneuf-du-Pape, the Pope’s home. He’s fancy and he drinks great wine, but the wine is really for the people. The reason why it’s been around for 10,000-plus years that we know of is because it’s what brings people together.
I love talking to people about wine history, how we got here, and why we have so many amazing wines. The screw cap debate comes up all the time. I will give you the science behind it and my hot takes on screw caps. My hot takes on why the wine industry is going through its little gyrations right now—most of it is self-imposed problems, but we’re going to get it right and be just fine.
Robert Feinberg: Right. Well, I know the science behind the screw caps is pretty solid, but it’s not necessarily as sexy.
Brad Beard: It is not sexy at all. I’m not kidding you. In Australia, when I was over there 20 years ago, they were first adopters. The guy that was coming out presenting the wine would roll the screw cap off of his arm and try to present it as beautifully as opening it with a corkscrew. It’s just not ever going to be sexy.
But here is my hot take where I’ll get some heat from my friends. When I sell you an $85 or $120 bottle of wine, and maybe for you that is at the top region of what you would like to have, but you want to have that wine for a special occasion. So you only buy one and you keep it for a couple of years. Then you have your family and friends coming over to celebrate this beautiful time together. You take this bottle of wine out, pull the cork out, and the wine is infected with TCA. It makes the wine smell of a wet basement or cardboard, and then it robs the wine of flavor. You’ve just disappointed these people on a really important situation.
Most folks will probably have some other wine, but the anticipation of having that bottle of wine—it’s happened to me many times. When I was a young wine geek, I was buying these First Growth Bordeauxs and saving them for the 10 years that Wine Spectator would tell me to save them for. Well, the wine never had a chance to get to 10 years because the cork was tainted.
Robert Feinberg: Sure.
Brad Beard: It does happen. Some people actually like the fact that you’re playing roulette with your wine—you may have a perfectly stored wine that goes completely bad. But I don’t like to lose money on that and/or be disappointed. So, I am moving to screw caps with my wine.
I dipped my toe in back in 2016 with some $80, $90 Pinots, and I didn’t get a lot of pushback. I do have some pushback from my long-term customers, so they just buy my library wines that all still have corks in them, and they’re happy.
Robert Feinberg: That’s fun that you’ve got the option for those who want to live by the seat of their pants.
Brad Beard: And one little note: then they say, “Well, you can’t age a great wine that way.” There’s the myth; the science behind it is true. You can hermetically seal up a wine completely with zero oxygen able to get to it. But what people are forgetting is that wine has oxygen in solution, and that oxygen comes out of solution as the wine ages. So even if the wine was completely sealed with zero opportunity to have oxygen enter into it, it’s still going to age. Now we can discuss how much it would age because of how much oxygen is going to come out, and we’re working on that.
I also as a winemaker have the opportunity—I don’t manipulate my wine very much, but two years ago I started working on an experiment where I’m adding oxygen to solution so I can see how that’s going to age. So I’ve got a beautiful 20-year project that I’m working on right now. I personally can tell you where my wine will stand as it goes along, if I’ve added oxygen to it or not.
Robert Feinberg: That’s terrific. Now, in your response, there’s a lot of science, but there’s also a lot of humanity. You mentioned something that struck a chord, and that is that wine is for the people. I’ll tell you, we had a little event at the house yesterday for friends and family, and it was just lovely. Without the wine, it wouldn’t have the soul that it had. A shared bottle, that ritual of enjoying it and laughing with family and friends—there’s nothing quite like it.
Brad Beard: It’s not. For me, it’s really amazing. People ask me, “What’s the favorite wine that you make, or your favorite wine that you’ve had from around the world from all the fantastic winemakers that you know?” It’s not the wine; it’s the people that I enjoyed it with and the time that I had. You absolutely can bond over beer and you can bond over a Manhattan. I know those things can happen.
My favorite glass of wine or bottle of wine—I’ll go ahead and admit it. My mom is not a big wine fan and she doesn’t enjoy my wine, and it’s okay. So when my mom comes over, I will buy the most expensive bottle of Asti that’s low in sugar but nice bubbles, and we’re going to have that glass of wine together and enjoy our time because she enjoys that with me. I wouldn’t get the enjoyment if I just pulled out my Cab and she had a bitter face and didn’t enjoy it.
When you go to Europe and you’re sitting in someone’s home, they’ve invited you in, so they’re putting their best foot forward to try to give you the best thing, right? So if I know what kind of wine you like, that’s the wine we’re going to be serving, and I’m going to make sure I put the food out. It’s about celebrating your relationship with the human and to make that connection. Honestly, I think that’s why I ended up as a winemaker—because I can connect with people when we don’t even speak the same language, but we speak the language of wine and food. I’m so, just, grateful that I can break bread and share my wine with people.
Robert Feinberg: Yeah, your enthusiasm really comes through, and I love that. I’m sure it translates into the wines that you blend and produce, particularly with the palate that you have. Palate makes a difference; it’s a skill that not everyone has. It can be refined, but you’re also born with what you have, and I appreciate that. I, like you, enjoy experimenting with different flavors and blends, and the palate really makes a difference. What is your take on that?
Brad Beard: Oh my gosh, all the time. It’s a small sample, but I’ve seen thousands of people coming through my tasting room and talked with them. The husband or the wife is really into the wine and the other person really isn’t, and it usually is because they don’t understand what we’re going for.
Because your palate is a spectrum, just like so many other things with humans. We have Navy SEALs and we have poets; we have people that specialize in different things. I am blessed with what they would consider a super palate. My taste buds are spread out all over my tongue, where other people have palates where they’re very regimented. So if your bitter detector is on the very front and you didn’t get that, that’s not going to help blend with it. But I can help you find wines that will allow even the people with palates that aren’t quite as sensitive as mine discover the joy of wine.
Robert Feinberg: Speaking of that, at the First Press Wine Festival, what wines will you bring to have available for the different palates? Let’s say somebody who’s new and doesn’t know much about wine at all—what would you recommend for them?
Brad Beard: So, a lot of times people will go with something light and fruity for the people that are just getting into wine, like a classic Rosé, or a Pinot Noir, or a GSM. So if you’re just getting into wine, that’s it.
A lot of people just getting into wine, there is something to be said about how in Europe, you’re drinking wine from 8, 9, 10 years old, so your palate gets used to these things that we call tannins. And the tannins help bring structure. It’s not really a flavor, but a texture in the wine, and it can be perceived as aggressive. So if I was trying to get people to understand Cabernet, I would start with an older Cabernet because those tannins and acids would be a little softer so that way it’s a little bit more approachable to it.
As people are learning about wine and I hope that people that have never experienced wine with winemakers standing in front of them, this event is exactly what the people that don’t know much about wine should be coming to, because now you’re going to get 20, 30, 40 different experiences all in one afternoon on different winemaking styles. It can vary from, like I said, a young, fresh, and fruity wine to something that’s well-aged.
I love it when people tell me, “Oh, I just don’t like this.” That’s okay, I’ve got thick skin. But I’m helping them and then I’ll say, “Why don’t you like it?” “Well, there’s something bitter in the middle that I don’t like.” Oh okay, I can typically get that down to a tannin or something that’s aggressive or not aggressive. I’m fortunate that I make up to 20 different varietals a year, so I do a lot of blends and single varietals—so I’ve got a smattering on the bar that can help hone these people into the wines they enjoy. And if you enjoy it, that’s a place they can start, and then expand their horizon and help train their palate to all these different flavors and things that they’ve got.
Robert Feinberg: That’s great. It sounds like Mercury has a pretty wide range that will appeal to beginners and expert wine drinkers alike.
Brad Beard: That is correct. I can serve you an incredibly sophisticated Sauvignon Blanc but it’s still very approachable to a beginning wine taster, a person that’s just getting into wine, all the way to my Reserve Cabernet, or to people who are fixated on Cabernet Franc and Petit Verdot—varietals that people don’t do as often, 100% standalone varietals. We can go to the full wine geek side of things or take you on the journey from the beginning.
One of my best friends—friend because he’s been a member for years and years and years—his father from the Midwest had never spent the time, and it’s just, what do you want to be educated on, and if you happen to like wine you can do it. He had what most people would say are “dumb questions,” but this is one of those situations where there’s not a dumb question. If you have a question about wine, I’ll be more than happy to tell you, no matter how basic it is.
My vet, when I take my dog to the vet and say, “Hey, it’s not feeling good,” the vet isn’t mean to me because I didn’t know why my dog was sick in this way. I try to have that same approach and just help you understand everything. And then you have a better knowledge of wine, which means you’re going to experience it more, which means that we’re going to have a better time together.
Robert Feinberg: Sure, totally makes sense. I couldn’t help but notice that during our talk today, you’ve weaved in Europe, as you probably should. Any good wine aficionado knows a little something about the French, and the Italians, and the Spanish, and all that beautiful Old World influence. And I saw that you produce Bordeaux, Bordeaux-like, I should say, ’cause you’re not obviously in Bordeaux. But how do you do that when you’ve got California terroir and don’t have the limestone that they have in France? Tell us how you are able to blend so that you can mimic and reproduce something that you’re proud of and you can say it’s similar to a Bordeaux?
Brad Beard: Oh my gosh, that is a great question. We’ll see how many hours this interview is going to go on, but I will get it in a nutshell.
You mentioned the limestone and I will circle back to that. When we’re talking about Bordeaux, you’ve got the Left Bank, which is a hilly area, not a lot of valley floor, and that’s going to be good for producing Cabernet and Cabernet Franc. Over on the Right Bank, like Château Pétrus—one of the most iconic Bordeaux houses, which produces Merlot. I try to produce some Merlot similar to there. Over on that bank, you’re going to get a lot more clay and you could have some gravelly, loamy areas, as well.
Just in Alexander Valley alone, we have 28 different types of soil, everything from volcanic down to that clay. And so loam is on our valley floor, we have the Russian River running through our valley, just like every other iconic valley that’s not right on the coast. The Russian River provides me this clay and soil that allows me to produce an amazing Merlot.
Now the American Merlot, in the ’90s, because Merlot was losing its value, people were learning about Cabernet, so people tried to make Merlot as bold as Cabernet. But when I say that I’m making a Bordeaux-style wine—Merlot is not supposed to be highly tannic like Cabernet. I can make it highly tannic by over-oaking and over-extracting it, but I didn’t want to do that. A lot of Americans did, so Merlot became this thing where you didn’t know what you were going to get.
Merlot is supposed to have a silky character to it with beautiful cherries and plums, and the tannins are not supposed to be aggressive. Because it doesn’t have aggressive tannins, that means that Merlot should be paired with things that have lower fat. So if you were a person that were just coming in and you bought a Merlot and then all of a sudden it tasted like Cab, you didn’t like it, and so you Merlot is kind of gyrating back and forth. When I say Bordeaux-style and I say Right Bank, I mean it’s going to be Merlot-based and have a soft and silky character to its palate, unlike Cabernet. And so that’s how I can say that I’m making a Bordeaux-style wine, and of course, I’m using the five noble grapes like Cabernet, Cabernet Franc, Merlot, or Petit Verdot.
Robert Feinberg: Right. And I saw you also do a little Rioja and Rhône style.
Brad Beard: Oh my gosh, so here’s the deal. Tempranillo is probably one of my favorite grapes. Tempranillo I love because most Americans won’t spend the time making it right. In Spain, Crianza: two years of aging. In America, you can have a reserve wine from a named winery with two years of barrel aging and then they just hand you the bottle. Reserva doesn’t happen until four, and Gran Reserva is eight. Right now, my Tempranillo, which is 100% Tempranillo, my current vintage is 2017. And why is that? Because it just takes forever to be fantastic; it is a bold and intense grape, and you will miss out on subtleties and nuances if it’s much younger.
So I love that, but then my favorite—I don’t know if it’s my favorite region but darn it—the Rhône Valley is a nice long valley going everywhere from light and fruity wines in Provence to Châteauneuf-du-Pape, and then the Syrah mecca of the world is the Hermitage and Côte-Rôtie area. I love blending, I love doing the classic Grenache-Syrah-Mourvèdre blend, and I also do Syrah as a standalone wine as well and I try to mimic the amazing wines that come from the Rhône region. And I can do that because we’ve got so many sun aspects and so many microclimates. We’re coastal, but inland just enough to get some heat. It’s just fantastic.
Robert Feinberg: That’s terrific. So a funny/not funny question: was your Merlot production hit at all when the movie Sideways came out, as many of my winemaking friends observed back in the day?
Brad Beard: Here is the deal. I’ve been in the business for the entire process of this, and honestly, my hot take up front is that Merlot deserved to take the hit. Because like I said, some people made Merlot way too powerful, and the other people made Merlot with sugar and it was thin and uninteresting and just because Merlot sold. So I’m glad it had a reset.
But I was here for it and people would say, “Oh no, no Merlot, thank you very much,” and I would say, “But you haven’t had mine.” Honestly, I make 150, 200 cases of production for all my wines, so everything sells out. But my Merlot is my number one, it’s the fastest to sell out every single year, after year. It actually helped me because people stopped making it or even saying that Merlot was in there, so the people that were hunting for good Merlot came and found me.
Robert Feinberg: It’s a fantastic grape in the right hands, but like you said, if you bastardize it, and you try to make it like a Cabernet, it’ll be terrible. So perhaps it did deserve a little hit. Mostly in Napa, they took a hit from that, but Napa is doing good things now too, again reflecting more Old World thinking and moving a little bit away from that traditional American palate.
Brad Beard: The pendulum swings, and I am now old enough to have seen it swing. Not that I was—Napa hasn’t had an issue, but they’re fixing their issue. Their issue was they got too fancy and too focused on one goal, which was a super high rating. And then if your neighbor got a high rating and sold their wine, the winemaker next door said, “I’m going to make my wine like that.”
You’re supposed to be able to go to 10 wineries, have 10 different Cabs, and they should all taste different. They should not taste the same. It’s not the McDonald’s or Kentucky Fried Chicken of America where somebody said this is a pinnacle and everybody made their wine to that. Nowhere else in the world anybody is trying to make their wine like their neighbor; they’re trying to stand out and tweak the thing. And my vintage from vintage to vintage should be different. You should not have the same vintage, you should say, “What vintage should we be having tonight, my dear?”
So, we Americans, Napa just did its thing, but economics were at play too—this was a young wine-consuming nation, so you needed to have wine that was consistent. That was a positive because it got more people to drink wine. Because if you were going to pay $8 for Kendall-Jackson’s Vintner’s Reserve in Oklahoma City, or in Dallas, or in Phoenix, Arizona, it did have to taste the same. Because if you had never had wine or much wine before and realized it’s supposed to taste different each year—it was good for marketing, to help more people understand wine.
But you should have your favorite winemaker, you should have your favorite style of wine, and that should encompass four or five different people that make your favorite varietal because they should be different, not because they taste the same.
Robert Feinberg: As we wind down the interview, I realize I’d be remiss if I didn’t cover a little bit on your white wines. Tell us about those briefly.
Brad Beard: All right, that’s going to be tough, but here’s the deal. As I was growing up, Sauvignon Blanc and Chardonnay were really the only two white wines people that would consider were good to drink. Of course, we had sweet Rieslings and Gewürztraminers, but not all Rieslings are sweet.
Robert Feinberg: Heavens, thank you for that. There’s nothing like a dry Riesling; that’s one of the best wines in the world.
Brad Beard: It is one of the best for good reason, but what America was brought up on was the sugary sweet stuff and so that’s what they think it is.
Robert Feinberg: That’s why we need people like you because that’s just tragic that people think that, but they do, you’re right. I think at the Festival you can help educate people.
Brad Beard: Every day people walk in and I say, “I’ve got Gewürztraminer,” and they say, “No thank you, I don’t drink sweet wine.” I say, “Thank you, I don’t make sweet wine unless it’s supposed to be.”
Robert Feinberg: I love that.
Brad Beard: The only thing sweet I make is my Port-style wine, is the only thing that has residual sugar, and then that residual sugar is two points less than what they would have over in Portugal because I don’t think you need to have that much sugar even in a dessert wine.
Viognier got a bad rap in the United States. What a beautiful wine with wonderful aromatics! But winemakers, because people didn’t know the word Viognier, or Vee Og Ner if you read it for the first time on a label, so they made it taste like Chardonnay. It’s not Chardonnay; it’s supposed to be a lighter body than Chardonnay with more aromatics. And so people miss out on honeysuckle and jasmine on the nose and then you put oak and butter on it and then you lose all of that and then it becomes an uninteresting grape varietal. Viognier—stunning.
I also make a dry Gewürztraminer. With my Rosés, I call one of my Rosés Le Classique. If you had your toes in the sand and you were in Provence, you’d be tasting a Rosé very similar to what I’ve got. And then I’ve got a southern Spanish or southern Italian-style Rosé that’s much darker, and it’s richer, and it’s closer to a light red. I love expanding people’s horizons and showing them all these different, fun grape varietals and different styles on how to make these different wines.
Robert Feinberg: Excellent. Brad, your enthusiasm is absolutely infectious. I can’t wait to meet you at the First Press Wine Festival, and I would encourage all of our viewers to go online and you can Google “First Press Wine Festival”. It’ll come up. The website is FPRAZ.org. Look into buying tickets so you can meet people like Brad and others who have a similar spirit, and maybe even make a new friend or two, enjoy some great wine, and have some good bites. It’s been lovely to meet you, Brad. I appreciate your time today and I’m going to thank you very much for this enlightening and really fun conversation.
Brad Beard: Oh, thank you so much. Thank you very much. I’m really glad to be here, and if I can get people excited about wine like I am, that’s my whole goal.
Robert Feinberg: Well, you do a great job of it. Take care, and we’ll see you February 20th, 2027, at the MIM.
Brad Beard: We’ll be there having fun, I promise. I’ll bring all sorts of great wine.

